The incident shows how influencer commentary can shape audience perception of socially charged games, impacting brand reputation and broader conversations about representation.
Life Is Strange 2 arrived at a time when narrative‑driven games were beginning to explore real‑world issues such as police brutality, systemic racism, and immigration. By following two Mexican‑American brothers on the run, the title offered a gritty, character‑focused lens on the American justice system, earning critical praise for its unapologetic storytelling. The game’s political ambition now feels prescient, as ongoing national debates echo the scenarios depicted in each episode, reinforcing the medium’s capacity to reflect societal tensions.
When Jacksepticeye released his 2019 Let’s Play, he labeled the game’s message as a “specific agenda,” sparking a wave of criticism from fans who felt his perspective dismissed lived experiences. The backlash resurfaced on X in early 2026, prompting a public apology in which he admitted naivety and expressed a willingness to learn. This episode illustrates the growing influence of content creators: their assessments can amplify or diminish a game’s cultural impact, and missteps can quickly become reputational liabilities.
For the broader industry, the saga signals a shift toward heightened accountability for both developers and influencers. Studios are increasingly embedding social commentary, expecting audiences to engage thoughtfully, while creators are expected to navigate these narratives with nuance. As gamers demand authenticity and representation, future titles will likely prioritize collaborative dialogue with diverse voices, and influencers will need to balance entertainment with informed critique to maintain credibility.
© Jacksepticeye / Kotaku
YouTuber and Let’s Player Seán William “Jacksepticeye” McLoughlin has apologized for criticizing Life Is Strange 2’s political commentary when he played the game on his channel back in 2019.
When Don’t Nod released Life Is Strange 2 episodically over the course of 2019, it attempted to tackle a wide array of political issues such as police brutality, racism, and immigration through the eyes of two Mexican‑American brothers named Sean and Daniel. The pair spend the episodic adventure game on the run from law enforcement after a Seattle cop kills their father and Daniel’s latent telekinetic powers activate and kill the officer. As they walk through the United States, they’re confronted with all sorts of racism, abuse, and systemic failures.
Life Is Strange 2 throws any pretense of not being a political story out the window before the first episode is over, and while this was a subject of praise for a lot of critics seven years ago, it was also a point of contention for players who thought its commentary was forced or heavy‑handed. Well, a lot has happened in the years since, and it’s harder to deny just how true‑to‑life Life Is Strange 2 was. McLoughlin, who played through the whole game in 2019, signed off on the final episode of his Let’s Play critiquing Don’t Nod’s writing as “pushing one very specific agenda,” though he admitted he was “not the type of person to tackle these sort of political issues” and wasn’t trying to “downplay” the realities of being brown in America.
“I feel like there’s a lot more depth to this than you’re really tackling,” McLoughlin said. “I hope I’m not coming across as ignorant or anything because that’s not what I’m trying to say. If anything, I want to learn more about it. I want to get into it and I want to understand what’s going on a lot more but these things just don’t really shine a light on it that much. If anything it is just shining a light on it and then taking the light off immediately. It does suck that this stuff happens in the real world and I really wish it didn’t. Humans are complicated and a lot of humans are fucked up and have no empathy at all but hopefully we we get to a better place soon and hopefully things don’t get worse before they get better.”
It seems the Life Is Strange community didn’t forget McLoughlin’s criticism. A thread recently started circulating on X asking fans to offer up “the worst Life Is Strange takes” they’d seen, and one fan responded, “White men playing Life Is Strange 2 and calling it unrealistic and too political.” Another fan tagged McLoughlin and said they were still waiting for an apology from the YouTuber for his comments in 2019, and McLoughlin replied by apologizing and admitting he had been “naive.”
“Did I really say that? Jesus! I'm sorry. How naive I was. I've learned a great deal in the last 8 years.”
— Jacksepticeye (@Jacksepticeye) [February 17, 2026]
While McLoughlin said back in 2019 that he hoped things wouldn’t get worse before they got better in America, they unfortunately have, and as more stories have come out about ICE’s violent treatment of immigrants and the abhorrent conditions of the camps where it’s holding detained individuals, it’s become harder for anyone to deny the state of things in this country. Life Is Strange 2 wasn’t overly political; it was actually pretty honest about how cartoonishly evil these people are. It’s a shame things had to reach this level for so many people to realize that.
Comments
Want to join the conversation?
Loading comments...