Relentless Health Value
EP513: Revisiting Cunning Anticompetitive Hospital Contracts, With Brennan Bilberry
Why It Matters
Understanding these contract strategies is crucial for anyone responsible for health‑plan design or policy, as they directly inflate healthcare spending and limit patient choice. With ongoing antitrust lawsuits and DOJ enforcement, the episode offers timely insight into how current legal actions could reshape hospital market power and potentially lower costs for millions of Americans.
Key Takeaways
- •Hospital mergers boost market power, raise payer prices.
- •All‑or‑nothing contracts force insurers to accept entire networks.
- •Anti‑steering clauses block lower‑cost, tiered plan designs.
- •DOJ antitrust actions target Ohio Health, New York Presbyterian.
- •Sutter settlement shows $575 million penalty for anti‑competitive contracts.
Pulse Analysis
Hospital consolidation has accelerated dramatically since the late 1990s, with more than 1,500 mergers between 1998 and 2015 and a 50% surge afterward. Larger systems leverage this scale to negotiate higher rates with commercial payers, directly inflating costs for employers, unions, and individual consumers. The shift is evident as the majority of physicians now practice within these consolidated entities rather than owning independent clinics, giving health systems outsized control over pricing and network composition.
The playbook for extracting profit from this market power centers on contract tactics that stifle competition. "All‑or‑nothing" clauses compel insurers to include every facility in a system’s network—or none at all—allowing dominant hospitals to charge monopoly rates even at sites with viable competition. Anti‑steering and anti‑tiering provisions further block insurers from directing patients toward lower‑cost, high‑quality providers, neutralizing tiered‑benefit designs that could lower out‑of‑pocket expenses. Real‑world examples, such as a $44,000 C‑section versus a $21,000 equivalent two miles away, illustrate how these clauses lock patients into inflated pricing.
Regulators are responding. The DOJ’s recent antitrust suits against Ohio Health and New York Presbyterian echo the precedent set by the Sutter Health case, which resulted in a $575 million settlement for employing all‑or‑nothing contracts. Similar litigation against Atrium in North Carolina eliminated its anti‑steering restrictions, signaling a broader crackdown. For health plan sponsors and large employers, understanding these contractual levers is essential to negotiate fairer terms, protect member choice, and mitigate rising medical spend.
Episode Description
Stacey Richter introduces Episode 513 of Relentless Health Value as a primer on anti-competitive hospital contracting with Brennan Bilberry of Fairmark Partners, setting up next week's interview with Matt Cantor, lead litigator in the Sutter Health antitrust class action that led to a $575 million settlement over alleged price inflation using market power.
Bilberry explains how hospital consolidation enables higher commercial rates and outlines a four-part contracting playbook: all-or-nothing contracting requiring inclusion of all system facilities at high prices; anti-steering and anti-tiering clauses blocking lower-cost benefit designs; price gag clauses limiting disclosure of negotiated rates despite transparency rules; and pressure on ostensibly independent providers to sell or align pricing with the dominant system.
The episode links these patterns to DOJ actions against OhioHealth and New York Presbyterian and emphasizes collective action, regulation, and litigation to address them.
=== LINKS ===
🔗 Show Notes with all mentioned links: https://cc-lnk.com/EP513
✉️ Enjoy this podcast? Subscribe to the free weekly newsletter: https://relentlesshealthvalue.com/join-the-relentless-tribe
🫙 Support the podcast with a small donation to the Tip Jar: https://relentlesshealthvalue.com/join-the-relentless-tribe
🎤 Listen on Apple Podcasts https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/feed/id892082003?ls=1
🎤 Listen on Spotify https://open.spotify.com/show/6UjgzI7bScDrWvZEk2f46b
📺 Subscribe to our YouTube channel https://www.youtube.com/@RelentlessHealthValue
=== CONNECT WITH THE RHV TEAM ===
✭ LinkedIn https://www.linkedin.com/company/relentless-health-value/
✭ Threads https://www.threads.net/@relentlesshealthvalue/
✭ Bluesky https://bsky.app/profile/relentleshealth.bsky.social
✭ X https://twitter.com/relentleshealth/
00:00 Episode Setup
00:38 Why This Matters
04:41 Hospital Playbook
06:59 Consolidation Effects
11:41 All Or Nothing
15:24 Anti Steering Tiers
22:12 Price Gag Clauses
26:22 Squeezing Independents
31:15 Fixing The System
35:15 Wrap Up Sponsors
Comments
Want to join the conversation?
Loading comments...