The Trump Administration Is Working to Reshape Immigration Courts | The Excerpt

Why It Matters

By politicizing immigration judges, the administration jeopardizes due‑process rights and accelerates deportations, prompting urgent calls for legislative safeguards.

Key Takeaways

• Trump administration fired over 100 immigration judges in past year.
• Replaced dismissed judges with six‑month temporary appointees loyal to executive.
• San Francisco court closure shifts cases to suburban Concord, disrupting hearings.
• Judges’ asylum grant rates used as political target, not reflecting case mix.
• Court restructuring exacerbates backlog, risking deportations in absentia.

Summary

The Trump administration is aggressively reshaping the nation’s immigration courts, firing more than 100 judges and dismissing another 50‑60 in the past year. Temporary six‑month judges, appointed by the executive branch, are replacing the dismissed officials, raising concerns about judicial independence and due‑process protections.

The purge targets courts with high asylum grant rates, exemplified by the San Francisco immigration court’s planned closure and relocation to suburban Concord. Judges like former San Francisco judge Jeremiah Johnson, who granted asylum in over 90% of his cases, have become symbols of the administration’s focus on perceived liberal bias. Critics argue that asylum grant statistics are misleading, as case mixes vary by district and nationality.

Johnson, now traveling the migrant trail after his removal, highlighted the human impact: immigrants he once heard were suddenly left without hearings, some deported in absentia. The administration frames these moves as necessary to curb a “loophole” in the asylum system, while the Department of Justice claims political bias among judges.

The restructuring threatens the integrity of immigration adjudication, deepening an already massive backlog of over two million asylum cases and undermining procedural fairness. Lawmakers face mounting pressure to overhaul a system that can be reshaped by shifting political winds, emphasizing the need for congressional reform to safeguard due process.

Original Description

The Trump administration's mass deportation effort has played out on numerous fronts since he took office in 2024. There’s been dramatic ICE sweeps of major American cities and a significant expansion of immigration detention. But the administration has also been working to reshape the nation's immigration courts and dozens of immigration judges across the country have been fired. What impact is this having on immigrants’ right to due process? USA TODAY National Reporter Lauren Villagran joins The Excerpt to share her reporting.

Read more: https://tinyurl.com/5c6em2nu

Sign up for our newsletter for the day's top stories, from sports to movies to politics to world events: https://profile.usatoday.com/newsletters/daily-briefing/