Who We Are: On Therapy (with Abigail Shrier)

Why It Matters

Shrier’s analysis spotlights possible harms in current child‑focused therapy, prompting industry and policymakers to reassess treatment standards and parental rights. The conversation could influence investment and regulatory strategies in the mental‑health sector.

Key Takeaways

• Shrier's books critique modern therapy's impact on youth
• She argues iatrogenic harm from gender‑affirming practices
• Highlights social media's role amplifying mental‑health anxieties
• Calls for policy reforms to protect parental rights
• Emphasizes need for evidence‑based treatment over ideology

Pulse Analysis

Abigail Shrier, a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute and bestselling author, has positioned herself as a contrarian voice in American cultural journalism. Her two recent titles, "Irreversible Damage" and "Bad Therapy," examine how contemporary therapeutic practices intersect with gender politics and child welfare. The City Journal interview delves into her transition from law to journalism, revealing a data‑driven approach that challenges entrenched medical narratives. For investors and policymakers, Shrier’s work signals a growing market for alternative mental‑health frameworks.

Shrier argues that many therapeutic interventions, especially those affirming gender transition in minors, can produce iatrogenic harm—worsening mental‑health outcomes rather than alleviating them. She cites case studies and parental testimonies that suggest a rise in anxiety, depression, and regret among youth exposed to untested protocols. This critique resonates amid a broader industry shift toward evidence‑based care, prompting providers to reassess risk‑benefit calculations. Companies that supply assessment tools or counseling platforms may face heightened scrutiny as insurers and courts demand clearer efficacy data.

The interview also highlights how social media amplifies mental‑health anxieties, creating feedback loops that pressure clinicians to adopt trendy, yet unproven, treatments. Shrier calls for policy interventions that restore parental authority and prioritize longitudinal research before scaling new modalities. For stakeholders in the mental‑health ecosystem—providers, insurers, tech platforms—her perspective underscores a potential regulatory wave that could reshape service delivery and investment strategies. Monitoring legislative developments and public sentiment will be crucial for firms aiming to navigate this evolving landscape responsibly.

Original Description

What does it take to write books that make the establishment uncomfortable — and keep writing them anyway?

Manhattan Institute senior fellow, contributing editor at The Free Press, and one of the most consequential voices in American cultural journalism today, Abigail Shrier and Rafael Mangual sit down for an insightful conversation. The author of two national bestsellers, "Irreversible Damage" and "Bad Therapy," Shrier has spent years investigating what's gone wrong in the institutions raising and treating America's children — and why so few were willing to say it.

They discuss Shrier's intellectual journey, the ideas and experiences that shaped her worldview, her work challenging the medical and therapeutic establishment, and what it means to pursue truth in an era when the cost of doing so has never felt higher.

Get the best of City Journal, delivered weekly:

https://www.city-journal.org/email-alerts

Follow City Journal on X: https://x.com/CityJournal

Abigail Shrier: https://x.com/AbigailShrier

Rafael Mangual: https://x.com/Rafa_Mangual

Chapters

00:00 Introduction and Background of Abigail Shrier

03:11 Transition from Law to Journalism

06:13 Investigating Social Issues and Advice Column

09:05 Exploring 'Irreversible Damage' and Parental Concerns

11:50 Understanding 'Bad Therapy' and Its Implications

15:12 Iatrogenesis in Therapy and Its Effects

18:03 Cultural Shifts in Parenting and Independence

20:56 The Role of Social Media in Mental Health

24:07 Navigating Risks and Building Resilience in Children

26:53 Policy Interventions and Societal Changes