CommoditiesMining

The Silver Market May Be Closer to Breaking Than It Looks | Andy Schectman

The Deep Dive
The Deep Dive•May 4, 2026

Why It Matters

Understanding who controls the physical metal supply reveals why silver prices can stay suppressed, and signals a possible supply‑driven rally that could reshape precious‑metal investment strategies.

Key Takeaways

  • •CME margin hikes triggered massive silver sell‑offs in early 2024.
  • •China’s record silver imports signal sovereign demand despite price collapse.
  • •COMEX deliveries consistently exceed 20 million ounces, draining market supply.
  • •Central banks or government entities may be orchestrating paper‑market manipulation.
  • •Gold and silver price drops mask strategic physical accumulation by large players.

Summary

The interview with Andy Schectman focuses on the mechanics behind the recent silver price plunge and the massive physical deliveries recorded on COMEX. Schectman argues that price movements are being used as a misdirection tool by powerful market participants, while sovereign actors quietly amass the metal.

Key data points include a 300% margin increase from $15,000 to $54,000 per 5,000‑ounce contract, record Chinese silver imports of 836 tons in March—173% above the ten‑year average—and monthly COMEX deliveries consistently topping 20 million ounces. These trends suggest a coordinated effort to force paper positions to liquidate, allowing well‑capitalized entities to take physical delivery.

Schectman cites the “Shanghai flip,” the 2024 BIS report, and historic examples of banks manipulating metal markets, including JP Morgan’s $920 million fine. He also references central‑bank actions, such as the U.S. Treasury’s Exchange Stabilization Fund and European banks repatriating gold, to illustrate how governments can sidestep market rules.

For investors, the takeaway is clear: price volatility may mask a strategic buildup of physical silver and gold by state‑backed players. Monitoring COMEX delivery data, margin requirements, and sovereign import statistics will be crucial for anticipating a potential breakout toward the $300‑$500 silver range discussed on the show.

Original Description

Register here for The 2026 Rule Symposium on Natural Resource Investing:
In this conversation with Andy Schectman from Miles Franklin, we discuss why he believes the quoted price of gold and silver is sending the wrong signal, what he thinks is really happening underneath the paper market, and why the most important story in precious metals may be the steady movement of physical metal out of the system. Andy walks through his view of COMEX deliveries, margin hikes, ETF rebalancing, China’s buying, and why he sees price weakness as misdirection rather than a clean reflection of supply and demand.
We also get into deficit spending, the deteriorating debt picture in the United States, what that means for currencies and treasuries, and why Andy sees gold as wealth rather than a trade. On silver, we discuss the kind of pressure building in the delivery system, the shrinking cushion between open interest and registered metal, and what investors should be watching if they want to understand when a bigger move could finally hit. If you value real mining conversations without the usual noise, subscribe to the channel and share this with someone else who takes this market seriously. That support helps us keep bringing on guests like this and asking the questions that matter.
#Silver #silverprice #Gold #goldprice #preciousmetals #mining
Catch our full suite of content below:
====================================================================
Looking for better insights on the markets? The Deep Dive Spotlights is providing exclusive industry insights from executives, insiders, technicians, specialists and more.
We're upgrading our Canadian small cap coverage from written to visual, hitting investors with a double dose of market insights to provide a special look into just what's happening in the Canadian public markets.
=================================================================
TheDeepDive.ca Team
Writers: Jordan Lutz & Steve Hyland
Producer: Chriz Rayos
Host: Steve Hyland
Post Production Head: Oveja Rayos
=================================================================
Disclaimer:
Not a recommendation to buy or sell securities. Always do additional research and consult a professional before purchasing a security. The Deep Dive and its affiliates hold no licenses.
00:00 Introduction
01:00 The Price Drop May Be the Distraction
05:23 The Silver Leaving COMEX
11:07 Who Has the Power to Move This Market
15:43 Why Debt Is Driving the Bigger Gold Story
21:45 What Gold Really Means at $5,000
30:43 The Signal That Could Break Silver

Comments

Want to join the conversation?

Loading comments...