AM Best: Florida Reforms Are Positive Developments; Underwriting Discipline Remains Essential

Why It Matters

The reforms and disciplined underwriting have turned a historically volatile market into a profitable, more resilient sector, reshaping risk pricing and investment opportunities in Florida’s property insurance space.

Key Takeaways

• Florida insurers posted $1 bn underwriting profit in 2025.
• Tort reforms cut litigation costs 68% significantly year‑over‑year.
• Reinsurance capacity expanded, rates expected to soften further.
• No hurricane landfall allowed budgeted CAT funds to become profit.
• Underwriting discipline and digital risk tools improve catastrophe resilience.

Summary

Florida property insurers have entered a rare profitable phase, highlighted by AM Best’s latest report. In 2025 the Florida composite market generated nearly $1 billion of net underwriting income and added $1.5 billion to surplus, the first underwriting profit in over a decade. The turnaround follows 2022 tort‑reform legislation that slashed litigation expenses, drove DCC costs down 68% to $131 million, and coincided with a quiet hurricane season that let budgeted catastrophe reserves turn into profit.

The reforms eliminated one‑way attorney fees, barred assignment of benefits, and shortened statutes of limitations, collectively curbing property lawsuits. Reinsurance markets responded with expanded capacity and lower pricing; carriers saw moderate rate cuts in mid‑2025 renewals and anticipate steeper reductions for June 2026. Improved capital positions and disciplined underwriting, supported by digital modeling and higher deductibles, further strengthened balance sheets.

Lauren Migro highlighted that DCC expenses fell from a 2022 peak by 80%, and that surplus growth now stems from net income rather than capital injections. Insurers are leveraging risk‑selection tools, such as advanced analytics and deductible adjustments, to mitigate future loss exposure.

For investors and market participants, the softening environment signals heightened competition, potential premium compression, and a more resilient Florida property market capable of absorbing a major hurricane without jeopardizing solvency. Continued reform benefits and disciplined underwriting will be key to sustaining profitability.

Original Description

AM Best's Lauren Magro highlights new research that finds the Florida property insurance market has become increasingly manageable due to recent legislative reforms, along with a light weather year that drove substantial earnings in 2025.

To view more videos, please visit http://www.ambest.com/video

Follow us on Social Media: http://www.ambest.com/socialmedia/