Desire To Trade (Etienne Crete)

Trading With Vs. Without Indicators: The Reality?

The video pits technical indicators against pure price‑action trading, featuring a full‑time scalper who has used both approaches. He explains why the debate isn’t about a single “best” tool but about fitting a method to one’s mindset and execution style. He outlines the advantages of indicators—clear, rule‑based signals, easier back‑testing, and suitability for beginners or systematic trend followers—while warning of their lag, potential over‑optimization, and the risk of ignoring market context. Conversely, price‑action trading delivers real‑time information, sharper entry timing and precise risk placement, but demands a steep learning curve and disciplined discretion. Key takeaways include his mantra: “price action comes first, indicators come second.” He likens indicators to answering the question “should I trade?” and price to answering “where, when, and how much to risk.” He also recommends a hybrid setup: structure from price, plus one or two indicators for bias or volatility confirmation. For traders, the lesson is practical: start with rule‑based indicators to build confidence, then gradually strip them away as skill improves, or adopt a hybrid model that aligns with one’s trading horizon. This approach balances emotional control with analytical rigor, enhancing consistency and profitability.