You're Wasting Your Amex Points and Amex Just Proved It

Upgraded Points
Upgraded PointsApr 7, 2026

Why It Matters

Understanding the true value of Amex points prevents costly mis‑redemptions and helps travelers maximize rewards through strategic transfers and card selection.

Key Takeaways

  • Most Amex members redeem points for low‑value gift cards
  • Statement‑credit redemptions average 50,000 points for $300 per redemption
  • Transferring points without a specific plan reduces flexibility and value
  • Transfer bonuses can backfire if partner programs devalue points
  • Evaluate card benefits against personal travel habits and fees

Summary

The video dissects a recent American Express email that revealed how members actually use their Membership Rewards points. Contrary to the common belief that transfers dominate, the data showed the top three redemptions were gift cards, statement credits, and checkout purchases – all relatively low‑value options.

Key insights include an average redemption of 50,000 points for a $300 statement credit, and the warning that transferring points without a concrete redemption plan can lock users into partner programs that may devalue the currency at any time. Transfer bonuses, while enticing, often mask the risk of future devaluation.

Hosts Katie and Chris highlight the quote, “Members redeemed an average of 50,000 points to receive a $300 statement credit,” underscoring the missed opportunity for higher‑value travel redemptions. They also caution against chasing hype around new Amex cards without matching the benefits to individual spending patterns and fee structures.

The takeaway for consumers is clear: prioritize high‑value travel transfers with a defined goal, scrutinize card benefits versus personal travel habits, and avoid defaulting to gift cards or statement credits that dilute point value.

Original Description

Amex sent out a Points Pulse email revealing how members actually used their Membership Rewards points over the past year... and the results were shocking.
The top three uses were:
- Gift cards
- Pay With Points at checkout
- and Statement credits
All of which deliver a fraction of what those points are actually worth. We break down why these redemptions are costing you real money and what you should be doing instead.
Stream the full episode of The @upgradedpointspod here: https://youtu.be/SGF8y5yu7t8?si=ll8gBGH082JZshEk
Hosts: ‪@chrishassantravels and ‪@katiegoesthere
🖥 Website
✉️ Upgraded Points Newsletter
🎙️The Upgraded Points Podcast:
📲 Follow us on Instagram
📲 Follow us on TikTok

Comments

Want to join the conversation?

Loading comments...