Startups For the Rest of Us
Episode 805 | Gatekeeping Vs. Paying Dues, Raw Material, and Surrounding Yourself with the Right People (A Rob Solo Adventure)
AI Summary
In this solo episode, Rob Walling examines how founders should navigate gatekeeping versus earning their place by paying dues, emphasizing the importance of self‑education and effort before seeking community help. He argues that raw, unpolished material—early ideas and skills—outweigh polished presentations, as they can be refined into valuable startups. Walling also shares a listener’s quiet exit story, highlights that successful people are generally supportive of others’ wins, and stresses that surrounding yourself with the right network is crucial for lasting success.
Why It Matters
Understanding these dynamics helps founders allocate effort toward learning, network building, and resilient product development, directly influencing startup survival rates.
Episode Description
How much does your startup idea matter compared to your execution?
In this solo episode, Rob Walling covers several founder-focused topics: the difference between gatekeeping and paying your dues, why raw material beats polish, and why successful people don't mind others winning. He also shares a listener's exit story, discusses optimism in founder communities, and talks about the mix of luck, skill, and hard work needed to build something that lasts.
Episode Sponsor:
AI is transforming how people discover brands and Ahrefs is helping SaaS companies stay ahead.
They’ve just launched Brand Radar, a new tool that lets you track your visibility in AI platforms like ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google’s AI Overviews. See how you stack up against competitors, monitor reputation, and build authority across search, social, and AI.
No more cobbling together tools. Ahrefs brings it all into one powerful SaaS marketing platform, backed by 15+ years of real-world web data and marketing-savvy AI.
Try it free at ahrefs.com/awt.
Topics we cover:
(2:00) – Gatekeeping vs. Paying dues as a new founder
(9:56) – How “raw material” transforms into high-value skills (and startups)
(16:36) – A bootstrapped listener shares a quiet, life-changing exit
(18:17) – People who are winning don’t mind if others win too
(20:09) – The critical importance of who you surround yourself with
Links from the Show:
MicroConf Remote - Nov 5th, 2025 | Use promo code STARTUPS15 for $15 off your ticket.
The SaaS Playbook
1000-Gram Iron Bar Analogy
If you have questions about starting or scaling a software business that you’d like for us to cover, please submit your question for an upcoming episode. We’d love to hear from you!
Subscribe & Review: iTunes | Spotify
Show Notes
Startups For the Rest of Us
Episode 805 | Gatekeeping vs. Paying Dues, Raw Material, and Surrounding Yourself with the Right People (A Rob Solo Adventure)
Episode description
How much does your startup idea matter compared to your execution?
In this solo episode, Rob Walling covers several founder‑focused topics: the difference between gatekeeping and paying your dues, why raw material beats polish, and why successful people don’t mind others winning. He also shares a listener’s exit story, discusses optimism in founder communities, and talks about the mix of luck, skill, and hard work needed to build something that lasts.
Topics we cover
-
(2:00) – Gatekeeping vs. Paying dues as a new founder
-
(9:56) – How “raw material” transforms into high‑value skills (and startups)
-
(16:36) – A bootstrapped listener shares a quiet, life‑changing exit
-
(18:17) – People who are winning don’t mind if others win too
-
(20:09) – The critical importance of who you surround yourself with
Links from the show
-
MicroConf Remote – Nov 5 2025 | Use promo code STARTUPS15 for $15 off your ticket.
-
The SaaS Playbook
-
1000‑Gram Iron Bar Analogy
If you have questions about starting or scaling a software business that you’d like us to cover, please submit your question for an upcoming episode. We’d love to hear from you!
Transcript
Rob Walling: Today’s sponsor is Ahrefs… (sponsor read‑out omitted) …It’s another episode of Startups For the Rest Of Us, I’m your host, Rob Walling. In this episode I cover a handful of solo topics: gatekeeping versus paying dues, the value of raw material versus a refined version of that raw material, how people who are winning don’t usually have a problem with other people winning, and a couple of other topics depending on time.
Before I dive into that, MicroConf Remote is tomorrow, November 5th. It’s a completely virtual event. Tickets are $65 or $75, and we try to keep it inexpensive while still providing recordings. Even if you can’t show up, you can use promo code STARTUPS15 for $15 off. We have amazing talks lined up. Sonny Hunt will be talking about a 15‑minute intelligence framework so you can stop stalking your competitors. Victor Faludi will talk about turning demos into your best discovery tool. Greg Hewitt will focus on AI tools, and the recordings will be available for ticket holders at microconf.com/remote.
My first topic of the day is the difference between gatekeeping and paying your dues, specifically as a new startup founder. I wish I had included a reference to what triggered this in me when I emailed it to my Trello board. It was probably something on social media—I’m guessing someone was contrasting gatekeeping (keeping folks out of an inner circle where successful people mingle) with paying dues (having to earn your way in).
Gatekeeping is about “who” rather than “what” you know. Paying dues means you can’t just walk into a community as a complete newbie and ask the same basic questions that other newbies asked last week. We were all new at one time, but what I didn’t do was come into a community and say, “How do I find an idea here? I have an idea. Is this a good idea? I’ve built something. How do I market it?” Those are the same questions we see on Reddit threads, Hacker News, and other social media where folks want the answer handed to them.
That’s why we can’t have nice things in founder circles: if you’re a new founder expecting others to hand you answers or let you into inner circles without doing any work, you’ll be turned away. You need to do the legwork—Google it, read a book, listen to reputable podcasts (e.g., Startups For the Rest Of Us, Lenny’s podcast, Jordan Gall’s Offsite podcast, Omar Zen Holmes’s “$100 MBA”), and educate yourself on the fundamentals that are freely available or low‑cost.
There’s a reason the SaaS Playbook and my books (available for $10 on Kindle or DRM‑free PDFs from robwalling.com) are cheap: they’re part of a rising tide that raises all boats. If you’re new to a space and claim people are gatekeeping you, maybe that’s true, but more often you have dues to pay—education, upskilling, hard work, luck, and skill. Put in the work, learn from what others are building, ship something, make mistakes, and learn from them.
When someone asks me a question—whether on the show, in person, via email, or a contact form—if they haven’t put any effort into their problem or done any deep thinking or trial‑and‑error, I’m far less likely to give a detailed answer. Questions like “How do I market this?” are huge topics; I could write multiple books on them. The best questions I hear on Startups For the Rest Of Us come from folks who have tried a bunch of things, are at a crossroads, and say, “This is what I’m thinking. What’s your take?”
…[transcript continues]
End of transcript.
Comments
Want to join the conversation?
Loading comments...