This “Average” Cookie Beats Every Other Recipe

ChefSteps
ChefStepsMar 18, 2026

Why It Matters

The recipe streamlines cookie baking, delivering consistent, high‑quality results that appeal to both casual cooks and culinary entrepreneurs seeking a signature product.

Key Takeaways

  • Combine bread and cake flour for chew and tenderness
  • Skip traditional creaming; high fat/sugar dough tolerates overmixing
  • Chill dough overnight for even hydration and reduced spread
  • Use oil spray on parchment to control cookie spread
  • Bake 350°F 12‑13 minutes for balanced crisp‑chewy texture

Summary

The video introduces the “ultimate average cookie,” a single recipe that delivers chewiness, crispness, and buttery richness without compromise. By blending bread flour for stretch and cake flour for tenderness, the baker sidesteps the traditional creaming step, relying on the dough’s high fat and sugar content to tolerate mixing without becoming tough.

Key techniques include portioning 100‑gram dough balls, lightly oiling the baking surface to limit spread, and chilling the dough overnight to fully hydrate the flour blend. The cookies bake at 350°F for roughly 12‑13 minutes, producing a lifted edge that signals a fully set bottom while the interior remains soft and melty.

The creator emphasizes visual cues—edges lifting, a firm yet pliable structure, and a minimal crispy rim—as proof of the cookie’s balanced texture. A ring mold is used to tidy the edges, and a gentle jiggle after removal ensures the cookie sets without cracking.

For home bakers, this method offers a reliable, repeatable way to achieve professional‑grade cookies without extensive trial‑and‑error, potentially setting a new standard for everyday baking routines.

Original Description

There is no reason this cookie should work.
We analyzed 10 of the best chocolate chip cookie recipes in the world… then averaged every ingredient to create one “perfectly average” formula.
The result? Chewy centers, crisp edges, balanced sweetness, and chocolate in every bite.
This is what happens when baking becomes engineering.
INGREDIENTS
200g cake flour
200g bread flour
287g unsalted butter
213g sugar
213g brown sugar
2 eggs
11g vanilla
5g baking soda
5g salt
436g chocolate chips
METHOD
Mix → portion → chill → bake
350°F / 177°C (convection) or 375°F / 191°C
12–16 minutes

Comments

Want to join the conversation?

Loading comments...