Does Human Longing Point to God? | Alister McGrath
Why It Matters
If human yearning reflects a deeper, possibly divine, need, it reshapes how societies address purpose, ethics, and the search for meaning, influencing both personal belief systems and broader cultural narratives.
Key Takeaways
- •Human longing hints at a transcendent reality beyond experience.
- •C.S. Lewis argues restlessness reflects innate desire for God.
- •Christian worldview aligns theory with observed human dissatisfaction.
- •Church history shows persistent quest for correct doctrinal language.
- •Debate suggests faith offers coherent pattern over evolutionary explanations.
Summary
Alister McGrath explores whether the universal human sense of yearning points toward a divine source, framing the discussion around C.S. Lewis’s argument that our restlessness is not random but signals a horizon beyond material existence. He juxtaposes this theological perspective with evolutionary psychology, noting that while the latter can offer mechanistic explanations, it often feels like a post‑hoc story lacking the depth of the Christian narrative.
McGrath cites Augustine’s famous line—“our heart is restless until it finds its rest in you”—to illustrate how Christian doctrine predicts the very longing he observes. He argues that the resonance between this theological “theory” and the lived experience of dissatisfaction provides a suggestive, though not conclusive, fit that evolutionary accounts struggle to match. The conversation also touches on how church history, despite its wars and schisms, reveals a persistent drive to articulate an ineffable reality through doctrine and language.
Specific examples include the centuries‑long Christological debates, where theologians painstakingly examined every nuance to capture the truth about Jesus’ nature. McGrath likens these doctrinal struggles to humanity’s broader quest for the right words to describe the divine, echoing Ludwig Wittgenstein’s observation that language can never fully capture certain experiences—like the smell of coffee, let alone God.
The implication is that the pattern of longing, doctrinal refinement, and historical quest for meaning may offer a more coherent worldview than a purely materialist account. For believers, it reinforces apologetic arguments; for skeptics, it invites a re‑examination of whether human dissatisfaction is merely evolutionary noise or a clue to something transcendent.
Comments
Want to join the conversation?
Loading comments...