If There Is No Free Will Is There Individual Responsibility?

Rupert Spira
Rupert SpiraApr 11, 2026

Why It Matters

It shows that embracing responsibility and love‑based choices can drive effective leadership and personal growth, even when free will remains philosophically contested.

Key Takeaways

  • Responsibility remains vital even if free will is philosophically debated.
  • Consciousness is described as inherent freedom manifesting as personal choice.
  • Speaker urges living as if free will exists, guided by love.
  • Avoid victim mindset by aligning decisions with deepest understanding.
  • Choices should be filtered through love, not fear or desire.

Summary

The video tackles the apparent paradox between the absence of free will and the need for individual responsibility. The speaker clarifies that, while some argue everything is predetermined, consciousness itself embodies freedom, which at the personal level appears as the ability to choose. Key insights include the metaphor of God as a jazz musician—improvisational rather than scripted—and the recommendation to live as if free will exists. By employing our faculty of discrimination, we can align actions with a deeper sense of love and shared being, rather than reacting from fear or ego. Notable statements such as “consciousness is freedom” and “use your freedom in service of love” illustrate the practical framework. The speaker emphasizes pausing before major decisions—career moves, relationships—and consulting the deepest love and understanding within, thereby rejecting a victim narrative. The implication for audiences, especially leaders and professionals, is clear: adopt a responsibility mindset grounded in love and awareness, regardless of metaphysical debates. This approach fosters purposeful decision‑making, resilience, and a collaborative culture that transcends deterministic viewpoints.

Original Description

How can we lead our lives in a responsible way if there is no free will and everything is predetermined?
Rupert says: ‘I don’t think everything is predetermined. I think God is more like a jazz musician than a classical musician. It’s improvisation. I do think there’s freedom. The nature of consciousness is freedom. Whether or not we have free will is really a moot question, because ultimately there’s no separate entity either to have free will or not, but consciousness itself is freedom.
‘At the individual level, we do feel that we have free will. I recommend that you live your life as if you had free will, and that you use your faculty of discrimination and choice to determine a course of life that is consistent with the understanding that we share our being with everyone and everything.’
*This video is from one of Rupert’s in-person retreats in Norway, 22–25 May 2025. For more information on upcoming retreats (many of which can be attended online via livestream) go to:
Timestamps:
0:00 Free Will
1:21 The Nature of Consciousness
2:38 Freedom in Service of Love
3:51 Responding from Love
––
ACCESS FULL VIDEO ARCHIVE
You can watch or listen to 1000s of hours of teachings, guided meditations and answers in Rupert's full video archive here:
––
RETREATS (Weekend & 7-day)
Rupert holds regular retreats, roughly once per month, either in-person and online. Many in-person retreats can also be attended from the comfort of your home via livestream.
ONLINE RETREAT SCHEDULE
IN-PERSON RETREATS SCHEDULE (UK, EU and US) (Also Available to Join Online via Live Stream)
––
WEEKLY WEBINARS (2 hours)
Rupert's webinars take place on Wednesday evenings, from 4pm UK time. In the first twenty to thirty minutes, Rupert leads a spontaneous meditation. The remaining time is open for attendees to discuss their questions with Rupert.
WEEKLY WEBINAR SCHEDULE
––
BROWSE RUPERT’S BOOKS
––
LISTEN TO RUPERT’S PODCAST
––
JOIN RUPERT’S FACEBOOK GROUP
––
SOCIAL MEDIA CHANNELS
––
FOLLOW RUPERT ON MEDIUM
––
SUBSCRIBE TO RUPERT’S YOUTUBE FOR NEW VIDEO ALERTS
––
#rupertspira #nonduality #happiness #natureofreality #consciousness #awareness #meditation #guidedmeditation

Comments

Want to join the conversation?

Loading comments...