The Volokh Conspiracy - Latest News and Information
Technology Pulse
EMAIL DIGESTS
Daily
Every morning
Weekly
Tuesday recap
EMAIL DIGESTS
Daily
Every morning
Weekly
Tuesday recap
The Georgia Supreme Court identified multiple erroneous citations in a 33‑page order denying a new trial for Hannah Payne. Chief Justice Nels Peterson noted at least five non‑existent cases and five misapplied precedents, some directly lifted from the state’s 37‑page AI‑generated proposed order. Prosecutor Leslie blamed a revised draft, but the court traced the flawed references to the original AI‑assisted filing. The incident spotlights the risks of relying on generative AI for legal documents without rigorous human oversight.
A Texas Court of Appeals ruled that Elon Musk’s X comments about a college student alleged to be a federal agent constitute protected opinion, not defamation. The plaintiff, Brody, was deemed a private figure, limiting any potential damages. The court...
Judge Victor Bolden issued a permanent injunction prohibiting attorney Jeffrey Bagnell from using a five‑minute animation that falsely depicts a Sig Sauer P320 pistol discharging without a trigger pull. The court classified the animation as commercial speech under the Lanham...
On March 3, 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court granted an emergency stay in the Staten Island redistricting dispute Malliotakis v. Kosinski, effectively ending the case before the midterm elections. The stay was issued per curiam without explanation, and the parties subsequently dismissed the...
A Saskatchewan judge awarded University of Regina professor $70,000 in damages, finding she was defamed by accusations that she pretended to be Indigenous and used forged documents. The court clarified that the defamation stemmed from fraud allegations, not merely the...
The Maine Supreme Judicial Court vacated a court‑issued gag order that barred a mother from speaking publicly about her child‑protection case, deeming it an unconstitutional prior restraint. The order had prohibited any media interaction, social‑media posts, or discussion of the...
Washington Court of Appeals reversed a domestic‑violence protective order (DVPO) granted to minor stepdaughter Mia against her stepfather George. The appellate panel found the trial court failed to make the statutory findings required for unlawful harassment, stalking, or coercive control,...
A federal district court in Pennsylvania ruled that NYU and its law school’s report summarizing a 2007 prosecutorial‑misconduct filing is protected by New York’s absolute fair‑report privilege. The court found the report to be a substantially accurate, often verbatim, summary...
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit affirmed a district court’s denial of pseudonym motions filed by three plaintiffs alleging Sean Combs sexually assaulted them between 1991 and 2007. The panel applied the ten‑factor *Sealed Plaintiff* test and...
Magistrate Judge Stephanie Christensen found that both parties in Creditors Adjustment Bureau, Inc. v. All Season Power LLC cited a non‑existent case and fabricated quotations, likely generated by artificial‑intelligence tools. Plaintiff’s brief contained four false citations, and the defendant inadvertently...
The Sixth Circuit sanctioned attorneys Van Irion and Russ Egli for repeatedly citing nonexistent cases in appeals stemming from the City of Athens fireworks litigation. The court identified more than two dozen fabricated citations and ordered the lawyers to reimburse...
A federal judge in the Elephant Shoe, LLC v. Cook case issued an injunction prohibiting defendants from copying the judge and magistrate on emails sent to third parties, a practice barred by Local Rule 7.1(M). The judge noted that the...
The Ninth Circuit refused to rehear en banc the Olympus Spa v. Armstrong case, leaving the panel majority’s decision intact. Judge VanDyke’s lead dissent opened with a graphic description of "swinging dicks," sparking a sharp rebuke from 28 of his...
Judge Pauline Newman, a senior Federal Circuit judge, has filed a petition for certiorari asking the Supreme Court to review her removal from active service by fellow judges. The D.C. Circuit previously held that the Judicial Councils Reform and Judicial...
The Fourth Circuit issued a public admonishment to attorney Eric Nwaubani after his appellate briefs cited three nonexistent judicial opinions, a mistake the court linked to possible generative AI use. The panel found his conduct violated Local Rule 46(g)(1)(c) and...
