How Influence Really Works in Modern Leadership

Why It Matters

Understanding when and how to deploy dominant versus collaborative leadership is critical for CEOs navigating crises, ensuring decisions are both swift and sustainable in an increasingly complex, multi‑generational workplace.

Key Takeaways

• Economic uncertainty spikes demand for dominant, assertive leaders.
• Dominant leaders provide vision but risk unsustainable, autocratic decisions.
• Effective crisis leadership balances decisive control with team empowerment.
• Timing dictates when wartime versus peacetime leadership styles succeed.
• Multi‑generational workforces require adaptable, less coercive leadership approaches.

Summary

The Think Ahead podcast episode examines how influence operates in modern leadership, especially under layered crises such as supply‑chain disruptions, rapid AI change, and climate threats. Professor Nerra Sivanatan presents cross‑national research covering 69 countries and 140,000 respondents, showing that heightened economic uncertainty dramatically raises the appeal of dominant, assertive leaders who make unilateral decisions.

The discussion highlights that while dominant leaders can deliver a clear vision quickly—a necessity when teams are paralyzed by ambiguity—they often struggle to sustain transformations. Diana Torres stresses the "power of three" framework: a concise vision, three strategic focus areas, and empowerment of employees to execute. Without genuine empowerment, turnarounds may be short‑lived, reverting to pre‑crisis problems.

The guests invoke psychological theory of compensatory control, explaining why people cede autonomy to confident leaders during crises. Historical analogues—Lincoln’s wartime decisiveness, Churchill’s autocratic wartime governance versus Eisenhower’s consensus‑driven peace‑time leadership—illustrate the timing of dominant versus collaborative styles. Modern leaders must also navigate a multi‑generational workforce that resists command‑and‑control approaches.

Ultimately, effective leadership in today’s volatile environment requires a duality: the ability to act decisively when stakes are high, coupled with the humility to delegate, listen, and sustain change through empowered teams. Companies that master this balance are better positioned for resilient, long‑term growth.

Original Description

In a world defined by uncertainty, the leaders who thrive are those who understand how influence, trust and human psychology shape decision-making and team performance.

In this episode of Think Ahead, Sergei Guriev, Professor of Economics and Dean at London Business School, sits down with Niro Sivanathan, Professor of Organisational Behaviour at London Business School, and Diana Torres, Senior Managing Director at Teneo, to explore how leadership is evolving in complex, high-pressure environments.

Together, they examine why people seek strong direction during turbulent times, how leaders can set a compelling vision without closing off crucial feedback, and the powerful role of transparency in building trust. From managing hybrid teams to navigating crisis-driven expectations, this episode unpacks what truly drives influence in modern organisations.

Tune in to learn:

How uncertainty impacts the psychology of leadership and why clarity becomes essential

The difference between providing direction and limiting innovation

Why trust, accountability and communication now determine long-term performance

Practical insights on empowering teams, shaping culture and leading through complexity

Whether you are guiding an organisation through transformation or building your own leadership approach, this episode offers research-backed insights and real-world experience from two perspectives: behavioural science and frontline corporate leadership.

For more thought leadership and business insights from London Business School faculty and alumni, visit ⁠⁠⁠https://www.london.edu/think

Sign up to receive a curated selection of articles, podcasts and films direct to your inbox twice a month at ⁠⁠⁠https://www.london.edu/think?entry=true#subscribeScreen

Follow us on social media: ⁠⁠⁠

https://x.com/LBS

https://www.linkedin.com/school/london-business-school/

https://www.facebook.com/LondonBusinessSchool