EU Losing Credibility by Not Standing up to Trump, Former Top Diplomat Blasts

Why It Matters

The criticism highlights a credibility gap that could weaken the EU’s strategic autonomy and strain transatlantic trade ties, while exposing internal divisions over foreign‑policy authority.

Key Takeaways

• Borrell says EU fails to hold Trump accountable.
• Claims von der Leyen exceeds treaty foreign‑policy limits.
• Calls for rejecting EU‑US trade pact with 15% tariffs.
• Urges new EU diplomat to condemn all law breaches.
• Highlights Hungary, Slovakia veto blocking €90bn Ukraine loan.

Pulse Analysis

The controversy stems from a fundamental clash over the EU’s external action framework. Borrell, who served as the bloc’s top diplomat until 2024, argues that the EU’s foundational treaties reserve foreign‑policy competence for the High Representative, not the Commission President. By allowing von der Leyen to negotiate a trade pact that imposes steep tariffs on European exporters while offering concessions to the United States, the EU risks appearing selective in its enforcement of international norms, especially as the war in Iran escalates.

Internally, the dispute underscores growing friction between the Commission and member‑state leaders. Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez’s vocal opposition to Trump’s strike on Iran has emboldened critics who see von der Leyen’s approach as a political power grab. The proposed EU‑US trade agreement, signed in Scotland, not only threatens European industries with higher costs but also signals a willingness to accommodate U.S. policy even when it conflicts with EU values on human rights and energy security. Rejection of the pact could restore bargaining balance and reaffirm the EU’s commitment to a rules‑based order.

Beyond the immediate trade issue, Borrell’s remarks touch on the bloc’s broader strategic challenges, such as unlocking €90 billion for Ukraine after Hungary and Slovakia exercised a veto. The episode illustrates how divergent national interests can impede collective action, eroding the EU’s credibility on the world stage. As Kaja Kallas prepares to assume the high‑representative role, her stance on consistent condemnation of illegal actions—whether by Russia, Israel, or the United States—will be pivotal for rebuilding trust and ensuring the EU’s foreign policy remains coherent and effective.