Most toxic backlinks don’t require action, because Google often ignores low‑quality links without affecting your rankings. But certain backlink patterns—especially ones tied to manipulative link building or obvious spam—can still trigger manual actions or weaken trust signals.

This guide explains what toxic backlinks are, why they happen, and how to identify them using automated tools and manual review. You’ll learn when link removal or disavowal makes sense so you can protect your site without creating new SEO risks.

---

What Are Toxic Backlinks?

Toxic backlinks are incoming links that can harm your website’s visibility in search engine results pages (SERPs) when they form patterns that violate Google’s link‑spam guidelines. These links are typically created for SEO manipulation rather than genuine user benefit.

Google evaluates backlinks as part of how it determines your site’s prominence and trustworthiness. Editorial, relevant links can strengthen SEO, while links created through manipulative tactics are often ignored or devalued by Google’s systems.

When manipulative backlinks appear at scale—or show clear signs of systematic link spam—they can still trigger a manual action for unnatural links. A manual action can suppress rankings or remove affected pages from search results until the issue is resolved.

There is no universal or official definition of a toxic backlink. A link that looks suspicious in one context may be harmless—or even normal—in another, depending on your industry, site history, and overall backlink profile. Google therefore focuses on patterns of unnatural linking rather than individual links in isolation.

Google’s stance on links intended to manipulate rankings

“Links obtained primarily for artificial manipulation of Search rankings are link spam. Our algorithms and manual actions aim to nullify these unnatural links at scale, and we will continue to improve our coverage.” – Google

You can evaluate your backlink profile’s overall risk with the Toxicity Score metric in Semrush’s Backlink Audit tool, which flags links that may need closer review based on multiple risk markers.

---

9 Causes of Toxic Backlinks

1. Paying for Links

Never exchange money, goods, or services for standard follow links (links that can pass SEO value). If you do, the link should be qualified with a nofollow or sponsored attribute:

<a href="https://example.com/" rel="nofollow">Anchor Text Here</a>

<a href="https://example.com/" rel="sponsored">Anchor Text Here</a>

Typical activities that require qualification:

• Digital advertisements

• Gifting products for reviews

• Working with influencers

• Paying for directory listings

Check your “follow” links in Semrush’s Backlink Analytics tool and request nofollow attributes where needed.

2. Exchanging Links

Reciprocal links exchanged purely for SEO can raise Google’s suspicions if they are excessive or systematic. Review and remove any such links that don’t reflect genuine partnerships.

3. Engaging with Private Blog Networks (PBNs)

PBNs are groups of sites owned by the same party used solely to supply links. Google actively detects PBNs, and links from them are high‑risk. Remove or disavow these backlinks as soon as possible.

4. Using Link‑Building Bots

Automated programs that place backlinks at scale (e.g., in blog comments, forums, free directories) create spammy patterns. Avoid services that promise large numbers of backlinks quickly.

5. Posting Unnatural Links on Other Sites

Adding self‑promotional links in forums, comment sections, or social media solely for SEO can be treated as link spam. Qualify such links with rel="ugc" (and often rel="nofollow"). Example on Reddit:

<a href="https://example.com/" rel="ugc nofollow">Link</a>

6. Listing Your Business on Low‑Quality Directories

Directories with little editorial oversight or that charge for placements can produce toxic backlinks. Focus on reputable, relevant directories.

7. Creating Widgets with Links

If you embed a widget on third‑party sites, any link back to your site should be nofollow because the site owner has no control over placement or anchor text.

8. Mandating Backlinks Through Contracts

Requiring a backlink as part of a contract, terms of service, or similar agreement without allowing the publisher to qualify the link is considered link spam. Make such links optional and properly qualified.

9. Being the Victim of a Negative SEO Attack

Spammers may point large volumes of low‑quality backlinks at your domain to trigger a penalty. Google’s systems usually ignore these, but monitoring sudden backlink spikes is still advisable.

---

How Does AI‑Powered Search Change the Impact of Toxic Backlinks?

AI‑driven search experiences (e.g., Google’s AI Overviews, ChatGPT) evaluate authority, trust signals, and source credibility more holistically. Large or persistent patterns of manipulative links can affect how trustworthy a site appears to AI systems, influencing whether a site is cited or summarized in AI‑generated answers. Keeping your backlink profile clean helps protect visibility in both traditional and AI‑driven search results.

---

The Context‑Dependent Nature of Toxicity

Toxicity is highly contextual. A link that’s harmful for a children’s education site may be perfectly acceptable for a casino review platform. Foreign‑language links might be problematic for a local business but expected for an international brand. Tools like Semrush’s Backlink Audit surface warning signs, but human review is essential to interpret intent and context accurately.

---

How to Find Toxic Backlinks

1. Use a Toxic Backlink Checker – Semrush’s Backlink Audit quickly surfaces risky links based on dozens of toxic markers and assigns a Toxicity Score (0‑100). Higher scores indicate higher risk. Review anchors, authority scores, and the specific markers triggered.

2. Check Manually – In Google Search Console, go to Links → Top linking sites and export the list. Review each referring domain for relevance, spammy pages, or unnatural anchor text. Prioritize domains that link most frequently or recently.

---

How to Remove Toxic Backlinks

Request Link Removals

1. Identify the backlink in your audit tool.

2. Locate contact information for the referring site (email, contact page, social profile).

3. Send a concise, polite request explaining the location of the link and why it may violate Google’s guidelines.

4. Track outreach status (sent, opened, replied) and verify removal.

Disavow Toxic Backlinks (When Removal Isn’t Possible)

1. Use the Remove list in Semrush’s Backlink Audit to select links for disavowal.

2. Prefer domain‑level disavows to cover duplicate or future URLs.

3. Export the list to a .txt file and upload it via Google’s Disavow Links tool.

4. If you have a manual action, submit a reconsideration request in Google Search Console after uploading the file.

Caution: Disavowing should be reserved for cases with a manual action or clear evidence of manipulative link building. Over‑use can harm rankings.

---

Real‑World Toxic Backlink Examples

• Sudden Directory Link Spikes: A financial services firm saw 500+ low‑quality directory backlinks appear over a weekend, leading to a 40 % traffic drop. After failed removal attempts, they disavowed the links, which helped recover rankings.

• Negative SEO Attack: An e‑commerce retailer received 1,000+ spammy backlinks from adult sites and link farms, triggering a manual action. A disavow file and reconsideration request restored rankings within 45 days.

• Hacked Website Backlinks: A SaaS company discovered hidden footer links from compromised high‑authority sites. After notifying webmasters and disavowing unrecoverable links, the issue was mitigated.

• Expired Domain Redirects: A healthcare company acquired a domain that inherited PBN backlinks. Disavowing the legacy links and earning fresh, relevant backlinks rebalanced the profile.

---

Strengthen Your Backlink Profile

• Earn editorial, relevant backlinks that reflect genuine authority.

• Monitor regularly with Semrush’s Backlink Analytics to spot unusual patterns early.

• Focus on quality, relevance, and consistency rather than constant cleanup.

By understanding the nature of toxic backlinks, using the right tools, and applying careful removal or disavowal strategies, you can protect your site’s rankings and maintain a healthy backlink profile.